Skip to main content
Solved

Raill replacement bus in the UK

  • February 22, 2025
  • 4 replies
  • 83 views

On my next Scotland trip, I plan a stop in York on the way back before riding to Portsmouth to catch the ferry. Unluckily, it’s on a weekend (22-23 march) were all lines south of York are closed.

There are rail replacement buses running to Doncaster, and also to Selby and Leeds, all three in about an hour which then connect on trains to London, so in theory there’s no problem.

 

However I’d like to be sure if I can consider this reliable, or if it can be like “there’s one bus every hour and 200 people waiting so you will wait for 3 hours”. LNER says the trains may be crowded and advises to book, but nothing special about the buses.

Alternatively, there’s a regional train route that still works to Leeds via Harrogate, barely slower than the replacement bus, but the first train is quite late on the Sunday morning and I’d have to be sure it would run normally and not be overcrowded to decide to wait for it (otherwise I wake up early and take a bus asap).

 

At least, the good things are I will be in York on the day before which leaves me time to see in real how everything work beforehand and plan accordingly ; and the sunday morning is normally the least crowded period.

Has any of you any experience about the rail replacement bus system on a major British line ?

Best answer by ralderton

They are pretty good at organising the buses in my experience. You can never guarantee it will be smooth, because things can go wrong, but planned bus replacements like this are a lot more reliable than emergency ones.

Leave plenty of time and expect disruption, and you’ll probably be pleasantly surprised when there isn’t any.

The Harrogate train will be busy, as you say, and if it’s cancelled you’ll wish you’d left earlier by bus.

View original
Did this topic help you find an answer to your question?

4 replies

ralderton
Railmaster
Forum|alt.badge.img+6
  • Railmaster
  • 1537 replies
  • Answer
  • February 22, 2025

They are pretty good at organising the buses in my experience. You can never guarantee it will be smooth, because things can go wrong, but planned bus replacements like this are a lot more reliable than emergency ones.

Leave plenty of time and expect disruption, and you’ll probably be pleasantly surprised when there isn’t any.

The Harrogate train will be busy, as you say, and if it’s cancelled you’ll wish you’d left earlier by bus.


Forum|alt.badge.img+5
  • Full steam ahead
  • 4906 replies
  • February 22, 2025

You'll be fine. On Sunday mornings not many people are travelling either.

I was very surprised how empty a York-Edinburgh was at 9am in peak season (August). First train of the day and we were like 20 on the whole 9 carriages unit?

(Also surprised how late trains start running on Sundays but that's a different topic!)


  • Author
  • Full steam ahead
  • 18 replies
  • March 9, 2025

Thank you for your answers.

I decided to bypass the problem by staying in Leeds instead of York, so I have spare time to go there on Saturday evening ; and on Sunday I have several possibilities starting from Leeds.


  • Author
  • Full steam ahead
  • 18 replies
  • March 25, 2025

I had a look around in York on arrival on saturday morning ; there was quite a long queue of people waiting for the replacement buses but it seemed to keep people moving without too much problem and several of the buses/coaches I saw on the streets were not full.

The 18:12 Leeds via Harrogate train I used that day was quite busy but not full, and I didn’t see many people using it end to end (which is not that surprising considering it was - at least on theory - slower than the buses and not advertised as going to Leeds on the station boards).

The LNER Leeds to London train I took on sunday morning was, as far as I could see, about half full which is already a lot considering there’s a 9-car train twice per hour.


Reply