Skip to main content

Buying a reservation "on the platform"

  • November 16, 2025
  • 3 replies
  • 79 views

Forum|alt.badge.img+7

Recently we ended up (lost bag, found bag, missed flight, long story) getting an SNCF Intercites du Nuit sleeper at short notice.

Because our plans only came together 40 or 50 minutes before the train was due we were unable to buy the reservation online.  Because there were no staffed ticket desks we were unable to buy the reservation in person.  There were SNCF staff in the station halls, but none with the ability to sell a reservation.  This was Cannes on a busy Sunday evening and not some tiny station with 1 train an hour.

We were advised to wait until the train arrived and buy a reservation from the conductor.  Obviously this would only work if there was space available.  If there wasn’t any space we were happy enough to stay in Cannes overnight.  So, we waited.

The train arrived and we approached the conductor to establish if there was space.  He confirmed there was and we asked to buy the reservation.  He began issuing the ticket.

Or so we thought.

The whistle blew and he was about to be left behind so he jumped onboard.  We jumped on too.  At this stage (after lost bag, found bag, missed flight, etc . . .) we were happy to be on a train which was at least pointing in the direction of home.

Unfortunately it turns out that we were issued a penalty fare and not a reservation.  I have to be honest and say I’m a bit peeved with this.  The penalty fare wasn’t too bad (€75 per person), but it’s a good bit higher than the reservation would have been.  If the penalty had been something like €400 per person of course we would have stayed in Cannes, enjoyed what remained of the evening and got a train the next morning instead.

My query (to the community) is whether you have been able to buy a reservation *on the platform* before?

My query (to the company, not yet clarified) is whether asking the conductor for a reservation on the platform will *always* result in a penalty?  If this is the case, what approach, if any, can be taken when the train is 40 or 50 minutes out, online reservations are unavailable and the station is unmanned?

3 replies

Forum|alt.badge.img+6
  • Full steam ahead
  • November 16, 2025

Totally unacceptable behaviour that.

Asking before boarding, before travelling is NOT fare evasion or attempted fare evasion.

It is perfectly reasonable to expect that you are asking permission from an authorized person to travel without charge or in case of mandatory accommodation charges to only be expecting to pay the normal rate. Anything else should clearly be stated before travel begins, with the ability to refuse a requested additional fee without penalty, an option no longer possible once on board and the train has departed.

In all cases the authorized person can say yes or no, if yes then you are travelling with their permission and no charge for ticketless travel is warranted.

Good luck finding any of this written anywhere though, it is just convention/basic human decency, sadly not something that can be relied upon with certain staff members.


Forum|alt.badge.img+3
  • Railly clever
  • November 17, 2025

My query (to the community) is whether you have been able to buy a reservation *on the platform* before?

My query (to the company, not yet clarified) is whether asking the conductor for a reservation on the platform will *always* result in a penalty?  If this is the case, what approach, if any, can be taken when the train is 40 or 50 minutes out, online reservations are unavailable and the station is unmanned?

I haven’t been in a situation where I needed to buy a reservation from the onboard staff before boarding but I already read reports about successful reservations on international AVE when in France, on Portuguese trains and on Eurostar trains. Not yet on French TGV/Intercité.


Schelte
Full steam ahead
Forum|alt.badge.img+6
  • Full steam ahead
  • November 17, 2025

As far as I know, Eurostar staff has been instructed to no longer sell passholder reservations on the platform. 

On international AVE trains, it was still possible last time I checked (mid September 2025).